It’s late May and my cotton skirts and cream-colored ballet flats are languishing ignored in my closet because the weather is throwing a city-sized hissy fit. So in order to placate the raging beast and her growling posse of grey skies and surly winds, I present a loving laundry list of things that I love about New York, never to be found in guidebooks.
“It is a miracle that New York works at all. The whole thing is implausible.”
E.B. White
The city has a short term memory for trauma and disappointment. What can start out as a terrible day – spilled coffee on the subway, rain when you’re wearing silk, losing a metrocard – can be irresistibly redeemed by another random act, like the saxophonist playing a song you used to sing when you were young, or your fruit seller throwing in an extra orange, or turning a corner and seeing the sun illuminating an entire line of glass buildings.
“When you leave New York, you are astonished at how clean the rest of the world is. Clean is not enough.” – Fran Lebowitz
Reach is a subway musical installation at the 34th street N/R/W platforms. By reaching up and interrupting the light beams, you set off an individual noise, and there are 10 of them. Created by Christopher Janney, it’s this woodsy and ringing cacophony of surprisingly welcome noise in one of the smelliest stations in New York. It never fails to perk up my late night returns from Brooklyn.
“And we found other evacuees in the country who sat on their suburban lawns, planning to go back when the children had finished college; and when the rain fell into the leaves of the rock maples they asked: ‘Oh, Charlie, do you think it’s raining in New York?’”
- John Cheever
New Yorkers are, possibly more than any other city in America, here by choice. There are always easier and cheaper places to live. But the biting, scratching will to keep making it in this city gives everyone around you – yes, even those assholes on the morning commute – a certain glow, born from the active and constant effort of living out your dreams.
“This is the town that never sleeps. That’s why we don’t live in Duluth. That plus I don’t know where Duluth is. Lucky me.”
- Woody Allen
Taxis are one of my favourite things about the city. Perhaps to the very wealthy, it’s deliciously mundane to hop into a total stranger’s car and pay him money so that you just don’t have to think or plan or navigate for five to twenty minutes, but for me, it’s one of my top luxuries. Staring out the window from that uniquely lazy position where your head is resting on the pleather seatback, watching your poorer, daily self fighting the crowds or the rain, and knowing that all you have to do is pay and exit gracefully – it’s worth every overpriced penny.
“The city seen from the Queensboro Bridge is always the city seen for the first time, in its first wild promise of all the mystery and the beauty in the world.”
- F. Scott Fitzgerald
The 7 train is arguably one of the most enjoyable subway rides in New York. Coming aboveground in Long Island City, you’ve got a view of the majestic midtown towers and the contrasting low-lying industrial grittiness of southern Queens. Ride the 7 all the way out to Flushing one day, on a sunny summer afternoon, and stand in the very last car, looking out at the receding skyline from the back door window. You’ll want to turn around and go right back into the fray.
“New York is my Lourdes, where I go for spiritual refreshment, a place where you’re least likely to be bitten by a wild goat.” – Brendan Behan
The delicious close voyeurness of the city is probably its sexiest aspect. When I lived in the West Village for a summer, I saw an entire relationship crumble over the course of three months, in the swank apartment across West 4th. In June, it was all rooftop barbeques and laughing over bottles of wine, dancing across the parqueted floors for Mathias and Jorge (as we so named them). In the middle of July, Jorge started coming home late, lights turning off as he proceeded towards the bedroom, dropping briefcases and romances along the way. In August, there was a fight, curiously starting in the bathroom through frosted glass, a slammed front door and darkened windows for a few days as Mathias obviously went to the shore to collect himself. The apartment went on the market two days before I moved out.
“On any person who desires such queer prizes, New York will bestow the gift of loneliness and the gift of privacy.”
- E.B. White
I like meeting people in the wrong places at the wrong time. On a Friday night when you’re supposed to be out drinking or dining with friends, like the rest of New York City, I think the people that ended up someplace random are more vulnerable, more open for conversation. The supermarket deli counter is a good one, or a commuter train, or a bookstore, or the dog run at your local park. At the dog run, I finally started talking to the woman with the two-legged dog that I’d seen around the park for ages. She was a psychiatrist that had lived in Westchester her whole life until her husband died, and then she’d moved to the West Village, “to live near all the young people,” she said. I didn’t have the courage to ask what had happened to the sad and devoted dog strapped into a set of hind-leg wheels. I met a woman on the train that told me all about raising her family in New York City, and her son that had wanted to be an actor and was now going to law school, and how she worried that he wasn’t following his dreams. At the deli-counter at Trade Fair, I talked to a cabbie about cheese.
“New York is a city of conversations overheard, of people at the next restaurant table checking your watch, of people reading the stories in your newspaper on the subway train.” – William E. Geist
Stuart and I played fashion police once, for an hour. We sat in a relatively hidden corner of the Trump Plaza at Columbus Circle, just high enough off the sidewalk that people didn’t automatically notice us. And we critiqued, praised, slammed, offered suggestions for about two hundred people that walked by. “What is she thinking with those SOCKS?” and “I like that look for him, it sort of says ‘I hang OUT with gay men but I’m straight’, especially those shoes” and “what is it with STRIPES this season, everyone’s wearing them,” and “their styles don’t match at all, that couple isn’t long for this world”. It was amazing, and the funny thing was, I couldn’t stop doing it to people walking by OR myself, for about a week.
“And New York is the most beautiful city in the world? It is not far from it. No urban night is like the night there. Squares after squares of flame, set up and cut into the ether. Here is our poetry, for we have pulled down the stars to our will.” – Ezra Pound
The best thing about going away for a holiday from New York City, I think, is the feeling of coming back. When you fly in to LaGuardia, and it almost seems like the pilot is doing a sight tour of the East River just for you, or you coast through the airspace above Manhattan at night and the city lights look like gold filligree laid on black velvet and the bridges look like diamond tennis bracelets and you just want to cry because no matter how perfect Brasil or the Caribbean or Paris or even Cinncinati may have been to you, you realize it’s nothing, nothing’s ever, quite like home.“The city makes up for its hazards and its deficiencies by supplying its citizens with massive doses of a supplementary vitamin: the sense of belonging to something unique, cosmopolitan, mighty and unparalleled.”
- E.B. White




Krissa, I love when you write posts like this about New York. I, too, have fallen completely in love with this crazy city for many of the same reasons you mentioned, and after two years here I can’t imagine ever wanting to live anywhere else. If our fair city could read, I think she’d be darn proud of your words. I know I am darn proud to consider myself a New Yorker (albeit a relatively newfangled one) when I read them.
Thanks, as always, for sharing!
I’ve been reading petithiboux for ages, but this is my first time commenting — your post evokes the bimulous feelings i felt as i lived in NYC my summer after college. I hated my job, but boy — New York in the summer, even on the hottest, smelliest day . . . wouldn’t have wanted to be anywhere else. Thanks for bringing back that feeling! Especially on such a gray day.
there are so many reasons to love new york, and yours are often the most well-stated and resonant for me. you’re making me hungry for all those beautiful, unexpected but right-around-the-corner kinds of moments. perhaps i’ll be back in the fray next year…
Krissa,
Thank you for reminding me why I love New York. I, too, love flying back into the city. I still remember the first time I left after moving here and I thought I was going to curl over and die if I didn’t get back to this insanity.
What’s not to love?
Simply lovely. One of the best blog posts I’ve read, and I don’t bestow that praise lightly. Thanks.
I love it when you write about New York. And the assembled quotes are wonderful. Thanks for this entry.
Oh, yeah. I have picked up Passage by Willis after following your link to Amazon. I’m looking forward to it. In exchange, here’s a rec for Caleb Carr’s “The Italian Secretary”, which is first-rate Holmes tribute until it falls apart at the end, which come to think of it, was what usually happened in the Conan Doyle stories.
Thanks again for this entry.
Hi Krissa!
It’s me! Can you believe it…me venturing into the blogoshpere? Loved your post…here I am getting all choked up…I can’t believe I’m considering going to school in Boston. yikes.
no offense, Boston.
It’s true…no place quite compares to New York.
Even on the tiredest, grocery-carrying, smog-ridden, 168th St. 1,9 subway stop days…when I stop and think, I really don’t want to live any place else.
love ya!
Damn it, woman. Did you decide to write something this fantastic just to throw my own lame-assed silence into even sharper relief? Seriously, this is my favorite thing you’ve ever written. Ever. Fuck the breakfast bar.
Wow! That’s a great entry – the sort of writing that almost makes me wanna pack my bags and hightail it to new york.
Wow – I’ve never spent any serious time in NYC, but now I feel like we’re intimately acquainted. Which means: good writing.
yay now i’m even more excited to come back!
Ah, you just gave me a much needed, very eloquent dose of city life. Thank you.
As for the cotton skirts and ballet flats going neglected, you’re not alone. I live in the South of France and it has just NOW gotten warm enough to where I can take them out…
“What can start out as a terrible day… can be irresistibly redeemed by another random act…” YES. Perfectly stated.
Brilliant.
You captured everything I love about this city. And everything I love about the people I share it with.
Posts like this remind me why signing that obscene rent check every month is so. worth. it.
The next time one of my friends who owns a condo/home/luxury car someplace other than New York questions my decision to live here, where I decidedly do not own a condo/home/luxury car? I’m directing them straight to this post.
Krissa,
I’ll echo the love…that was a beautiful post. I feel all of that for Chicago, even on the bad days when I wonder why I’m here.
And I’m glad I’m not the only one who is enthralled with the idea of taxis!
flew into laguardia at night a week or two ago, and it really was cool as hell.
You, my darling, are bloody brilliant.
Wow. i didn’t want it to end…
The 7?! Are you INSANE?! I’ve TAKEN the 7 all the way out to Flushing, and I’m gonna be doing it for much of the month of July (and then taking a bus for another half-hour), and all I can say is, “EWW!” It’s amusing when you first get out of Manhattan, where the train feels a little like a roller-coaster, but two or three stops out, I start getting really depressed and thinking, “Oh. People have to live out here? That’s so sad…” On the other hand, you’ve included sufficient praise for Manhattan that I quite enjoyed this…But I still love Paris best.