I’m a reasonably happy person. In fact, I’m sure there are people out there that think I’m ridiculously happy, almost drugged with satisfaction, and usually these people wear much more eyeliner than I do.
And from my saccharine-soaked platform of jubilance, I rarely get really angry. I mean, I experience negative emotions. I get upset about being ten minutes late to a movie, I get frantic with worry about the tiniest things, I get practically frenzied about What The Fuck I’m Going To Do With My Life, and I get annoyed when there is too much cutlery stuffed into the drying rack.
But look elsewhere for sugar right now. I am a woman and I am angry. For almost two weeks, I’ve been trying to temper my stifling rage at the Melissa Summers/Today Show situation. A promient and witty female blogger goes onto national television, no, is invited onto a national morning show to talk about her moderate and sensible point of view that women, as mothers, shouldn’t feel badly or castigate themselves for having a glass of wine during a playdate with their children and other mothers. Summers is articulate, temperate, and RIGHT.
And she’s basically set up by the Today Show to be labeled as the opposite of “healthy”. She’s not sitting up there having a rational discussion about what it means to have a moderate glass of wine. She’s part of a segment where three other women, having one glass of wine at their playdate, are filmed through the glassy alcoholic necks of wine bottles, where they show the same wine-pouring shot three times. She’s ambushed with idiotic questions and not allowed to say what she means. She’s set against a robotic talking-head psychologist that doesn’t answer either of her points, and she’s confronted by Meredith Viera who basically equates her capable full-time mothering to a babysitter.
Not a single element of this entire charade is about men. We are not watching men having a beer while their kids play in the yard. We are not talking about the pressures of fatherhood. We are not even talking about whether a husband and wife can relax with a drink whilst watching their children.
THIS IS ALL ABOUT WOMEN, and only women are subjected to this ridiculous debate.
Because they are WOMEN.
I cannot stress enough the way my throat closes over when I think this through. My brain gets very messy, and very loud. I can only equate it to a room full of filing cabinets, half of them flying violently open by an unseen hand, papers and folders and documents all being flung into a snowstorm of information by some Carrie-like wrathful angel of feminism.
File folders marked with angry red letters about the glass ceiling for motherhood in the corporate world, about the inherently unfair standards dropped on the shoulders of working mothers. Post-its that ask, if there was an equally body-specific and private decision like abortion available to men, would there even been a national platform for outrage over their choice to do it? Whole cabinets full of pissed-off notes about being objectified, being forced to swallow lies about what Men Want and What Gets Them To Marry You. An entire drawer on the issue of weight and curves and aging and sexiness.
I am angry that segments about women like the Today Show segment even exist, because they are not complex and thoughtful evaluations of modern motherhood, they are idiotic and prejudiced stones of judgement that are all too easy to hurl at this society’s favorite punching bag. It’s like some horrific national itch that no one will collectively face and eradicate because it’s too fucking enjoyable to drag it out into the harsh light of day and watch it scab over again.
The anger is like a blowdryer dropped into a series of interconnecting estuaries and canals – pretty much the whole body of water is vibrating with electric current. I want to scream, I want to rail, because I am so tired of the millions of subtle little papercuts that women are still enduring. How inequal can we possibly stay whilst having all the shallow pinnings of equality? What will change people’s MINDS?
I am not an angry person. But I am angry because all this means that we still suffer under a Madonna/Whore complex in every aspect of our public AND OUR PRIVATE LIVES. Women cannot have a glass of wine when their children are in the house, but men can have a beer at a barbeque? Are women less capable? Is that it? Or is this because only the mothers are really expected to be responsible for their children where fathers are expected play a secondary support role? Men are still, what, the point person for hunting and gathering, so the role of motherhood is the only thing women should be capable of doing? Motherhood, a beautiful and powerful force, is used as a confining straitjacket by people who still want women to do it to the exclusion of anything else?
Aren’t we tired of cavepeople, of Venus and Mars, of Ozzie and Harriet?
Are we women, or are we solitary martyrs? Are we people, entitled to all the tiny triumphs and flaws and choices and mistakes, or are we templates and objects and standards and platforms? Are women allowed to be human, or must we constantly be either angel or demon?
I am angry about this. I am sick of this. I am sick of women being type-cast, stereotyped, generalized, judged, and ultimately penned in to societal expectations and mass castigation when they act out of form. Summers made a joke about sometimes rolling her eyes when her kids cry. This doesn’t make her a bad mother. It makes her a normal human being.
I am sick of women judging each other, like directors that gladly named names at the McCarthy hearings only to get the heat off themselves. I am sick of the Mommy Wars and the glass ceilings and the choice/life battle and all the little injustices that men don’t ever have to squeeze their eyes shut to avoid, just to have a day free of anger.
I want to see women turning this judgemental unfairness and inequality away at the doorstep, never allowing into their lives, and getting angry together at the slights and slanders against us. I want to see one giant feminist Care Bear Stare of rejection for these norms, these wicked compartmentalizations, these absurd expectations and inevitable failures of being a woman.
I am going to leave the burner on for this. I am going to stay just angry enough to keep the blood pumping and the adrenaline-fueled awareness on high. I suggest you do, too.




The thing that got me was that the conversation went from ‘So this is the situation, we have mothers having a glass of wine and socializing while their kids play’ and leapt, via a path that you rightly identify as being too easy to take – through being well trod – of ‘I am happy women are coming together and easing their loneliness and the trials of motherhood, but I don’t think they should do this around taking a substance’.
(or wording to that effect)
If you replace wine with something else that’s good only in moderation, say, food…which is something that takes up more airtime on that sort of show than alcohol, I’m sure…and how much different would that story be? It would have the same shape and format on the show, with the same sting in the tail, because they want to put it there to make a point.
‘Mothers come together for dinner’ would be warped into ‘Women gather to comfort-eat away the hardships of motherhood.”
why are you busting on cavepeople? haven’t the geico commercials taught you ANYTHING?
i was apalled too when the MOTHER was compared to a BABYSITTER! that went too far.
Hi Krissa! I’m bloghopping and came over here from Shivery Timbers.
What a great post you have here! You’re right on about the inequality of perception. It’s easy to vilify women in our society. If the Today Show had done a similar piece about men drinking while barbequing, it would be treated far more humorously. Men drinking = funny, sitcom material. Women drinking = Lifetime made-for-tv movie. Ah well. We can’t change the whole world; we can only change ourselves.
Ian
Yes I love this! I love that you’re as angry as me and that it’s spewing out all over this post! Good job and great writing.
Amen, sister. This whole Cult of The Perfect Mother is truly scary.
We thought you’d be interested in this statement about the whole wine-drinking-playdate thing on MSNBC. We have badges for mothers to use to take a stand on this issue.
Here’s why it’s okay for men to drink at BBQs: Because the women are sober and watching the kids! Because men NEVER watch the kids! Because that’s not their job! That’s what women are for! Right?!
This whole discussion just KILLS me. Thank god for alternative media sources like blogs to get to the bottom of unfortunate (aka outrageously injust) soundbites like the Today’s Show clip. I only wish as many mothers (and fathers) were online as watch tv.
this is better than a cup of coffee. you’re totally right. it’s ridiculous how the female double standard is still alive and well.
That was such a horrible hatchet job. Aside from what others have mentioned, I also found it curious how the “expert” was so opposed to drinking in front of children “to set an example for them.” But can we not be positive role models in showing self-restraint and moderation as proper drinking behavior? Or perhaps the only parents who are allowed to drink in front of their children are alcoholics, and God knows those kids are fucked already, right?
Not like unrealistic expectations of perfection ever hurt anybody.
Krissa,
Thanks for being so angry and so eloquent.
What really gets me is the mom-bashing. It’s the whole ‘if you aren’t doing something exactly how I think you should be doing it then you suck’ mentality. Cocktail playdates, bedtimes, breastfeeding, potty training, dinner cooking, what have you. It’s all ripe for judgement by someone else. And that is pissing me off.
Sexism? Also pissing me off.
Thanks for speaking up!
here via a post on maryann’s blog. This is STELLAR. We do need to hold on to the anger and the righteous indignation.
I love how in the MSNBC article, the author brings up, “Who would drive the kid to the hospital if the mother has had a glass of wine?” Gee, who drives the kid to the hospital if you are out with your husband and you’ve a 13 year old babysitter at home? THE AMBULANCE, DUH. Anyone can call 911. That is the dumbest argument ever.
Krissa, I agree 100% with this post. I am riled. I will stay riled.
I am so glad I don’t have tee-vee.
Firstly, I’ve never heard of Melissa Summers and I’ve been on the net for a long time.
Secondly, this women bagging other women scenario is old hat. Try watching Oprah – the psychotherapists on that show require therapy themselves.
But this is what happens in a society that has eroded every tenet of community and effectively erased the very concept.
Women in a cohesive community do not do this to one another. Women who are secure, confident and are in touch with their ability to nurture do not do this.
Rather than rail against the insecure rabble, look beyond to a much wider, vaster network that usurps the very thing you are angry about.
Life’s too short to be angry.
OMG! After carefully reading this last comment the word that came to my mind was POMPOUS. I had to go and double check in the Webster dictionary if I really had the right meaning…and I did:
“2: having or exhibiting self-importance… 3: excessively elevated or ornate rhetoric…”
Oh, her third paragaph tops it all! On which planet does she live? FPS.
Besides, to be angry is normal, VERY normal!
Krissa, I hereby give you the right to be angry (hahaha).
this type of thinking pisses me off, too. only you said it much better than i think i could have. so, thanks. and amen, sister!
here via maryann’s blog. This post is awesome. I’m forwarding it pretty much everyone I know male and female. I won’t go into what I think because the comment space is just not large enough to contain my outrage.
Someone left a comment earlier that “life is too short to be angry.” I competely disagree – I think life is too short to worry, and get stressed out, but never to short to get angry – because that’s when change happens. When enough people get mad and stay mad, change happens.
Gah! So true!
it was maddening how many times Melissa was forced to repeat, “ONE glass of wine”, since the interviewers were speaking to her as if she was suggesting dragging a keg, crackpipe, and herd of male strippers along to the playground.
It’s nice to see the large number of people standing by Melissa and her openness here in this little blogging community.
Oh good grief. If the girls offered wine at playdate-coffee mornings, I would certainly go to more of them.
Perfectly stated. Thank you.
This was SO well written and eloquent. I am glad that people have the guts to stand up for themselves. I was proud of Melissa for having the balls to do that! I wanted to punch Meredith Viera in the face for the babysitter comment!
Ooh, well said. I too have dropped the blowdryer now, having been gently simmering for much of my adult life. Much appreciated.